Monday, January 18, 2010

I believe you’ve mistaken me for someone who cares

I get it. The whole blogsphere gets it. WoW is a MMO, which by nature would dictate that it be a social game. I’ll admit that if it hadn’t been for group quests and early 5 mans, I probably wouldn’t be where I am today. In fact, I am sure I can place the blame for my WoW career squarely on the shoulders of our resident elemental shaman.

See, five years ago, I was the epitome of a WoW noob. I tried to run from Darnassus to the Eastern Kingdoms – and I figured the port HAD to be on the East coast of Kalimdor. Who would sail around the Northern tip? Somewhere along the way, I met some merry fellows, and we banded together for some great times. This led to joining their guild, my introduction to raiding, and my eventual budding as a MT/OT and Raid Leader.

The rest, as they say, is history.

I’m willing to try

I won’t lie, when I role into the LFD system I’m strictly there for my 2 Frost Emblems, and whatever shards/etc I can get on the way. Half the time I don’t even bother looting, as I’m working on keeping Divine Plea up and have to chain pull. I don’t care if the DPS is 1k or 5k, because unless we’re in HoR, I should be able to do enough DPS for everyone. Yes, it will be slow, but when you consider that freshly dinged 80 heroic groups were doing 4k as a group – my 5k+ while tanking will cover it.

I do however, make an attempt at civility. I say hello to the group, figure out who’s healing (I only use Grid, so the healer debuff doesn’t show – I wonder if there’s a way to do this), and hit a couple of quick macros.

“Hi, I’m Amathalanea, and I’ll be tanking for you today. My preferred method is to chain pull, however if you need a quest item, mana break, etc., please speak up early (i.e. before the pack we’re on is dead). I’m happy to slow down if needed, just please don’t ask me to stop as my shield is on the move”

“%Insert Healer’s Name%, please let me know when you’re set, and we’ll be off”

If someone else starts chatting, or if something profound has happened to me that day, I’ll speak up. I’m generally more talkative on my DK, simply because I’m a fresh 80 in all BoE epics and blues. I know there will be problems, so starting off nice can’t hurt. I figure it’s better to be up front about what they can expect – because my DK certainly doesn’t tank at 4k DPS.

Civility does not mean “I’m your friend”

There are limits however. Much like healers have their own rules you have to live by, I have my own tanking rules. Start pulling for me, open up with a string of racial slurs or general idocy, or tell me that I’m not in tank gear (Yeah dad, you told us) – and I’m much less inclined to stick around, and you can forget about achievements.

Personally, I think the achievements are great in dungeons. I recognize some are more difficult than others – like “Less Rabi” or the drake voids in Occ. This is why you have a guild, or a friends list. Hitting up a random group to do these for you is, in my opinion, entirely selfish. It’s even worse when you’re still sporting dungeon blues, and are obviously a freshly minted 80. Yes, I’ll help you get some badges, and won’t care that you’re only doing 1k DPS. No, I won’t wipe just so we can try “Less Rabi” again. I actually had a Paladin DI me while tanking him after we missed it, hoping to wipe the group. Fortunately for us, this wasn’t our first rodeo. We did have to wait an extra 4 minutes before we could kick him though.

I suppose it’s those kinds of folks – the ones who expect to take advantage of your good-natured personality. If the Red Proto-drake was a 310% speed mount, I’d be much more inclined to help someone. It’s just a regular mount though. I don’t see any reason to get bent out of shape over not getting the achievement.

Do it on your own time

In the end, it just comes down to my distinct dislike for folks that expect to be carried though content, and then ask for you to go that much further. It’s like picking up a hitchhiker, and them getting mad that you didn’t buy them lunch on the way; especially if they don’t follow the rules of the road.

As an example, my DK hit 80 this weekend. I leveled as a dual-spec Blood DPS/Tank, and spent my instance time learning the way of the DK tank. I know it’ll be different when everyone opens up at the first sight of a D&D with every AoE in the book – but at least I’m trying. I also dropped about 13k on world BoEs, crafted 245 epics, etc. I have no doubt that the iLvl 200 epics I bought will be replaced in a week or two – but at least I’m not walking into a dungeon expecting to be carried by the healer and DPS. The only thing I didn’t splurge on was epic gems – and that’s only because none of our JCs were on at the time.

So the long and the short of it is – we can be social; and I’ll even help carry your stuff along the way if you at least pretend to act like a decent human being. Treat me like some kind of Sherpa or worse (because at least a Sherpa is human) some kind of tank NPC who’s just there to do your bidding, and we won’t have a very long relationship.

Friday, January 15, 2010

My DPS are not interchangeable


Ladies and gentlemen of the blogsphere, I want to take a moment to put to rest a serious issue that has been floating around the internet lately. Primarily, this is the notion that DPS are just meat in a run – and that one is just as good as the other.

I DON’T THINK SO

Much like tanks and healers aren’t necessarily equal (to their respective counterparts), so goes the same for your DPS. While many tanks and healers you encounter in your random heroic are extremely over geared for the content and can survive anything short of a hard enrage, it’s your smart DPS that got you there. I’m guessing the only reason you remember the dumb DPS at all is the higher concentration of them in any given group – given the requirements of most raids/heroics.

Smart DPS can make you look good

Regardless of your personal feelings about the average DPSer, a smart player can save a run from a wipe, and make you look like the quiet hero you should be. Snapping off a quick stun on a loose mob, a timely counterspell or death grip, or simply waiting that extra two seconds before blowing up a group of mobs – all of these are done by smart DPS.

An unlikely example

Our resident mage and surfer of dark corners of the internet is, on the surface, the last guy you’d expect to fall into this category. I swear I’ve seen him flamestrike/blizzard pulls as their on their way to me, and it’s not a successful night unless I can get him cleaved or otherwise killed. Here’s the thing though – when needed, he comes through – regardless of the toon he’s on. I’ve seen him grip runners or casters into my tanking range (on his DK), sheep a mob heading for the healer (or more likely himself), and slow-kite something back to me.

Our rogue is the same way. Leveling up in BC (back where CC was really needed), I knew I could count on that timely blind/gouge to buy us a few key seconds. Sapping a target was just a given, and even now he’s always up there providing the utility required to make a run smoother. These are the kinds of actions I can expect from smart DPS. I don’t expect to see this from my run of the mill PUG.

I could list a dozen examples from all of our current guild members that reflect smart and heads-up play. Everything from the retadin off-tanking something for a moment, on the fly battle-rezzes, etc. Not to say their always at 100% - sometimes the Bowl game is on.

But they can’t out DPS the tank!

Odds are very good that everyone has run into this situation in a PUG heroic. The tank is 1st or 2nd on DPS (especially on damage done), and the rest of the DPS is lagging behind – even if their in comparable gear. While this would understandably be an issue in a raid scenario, and it is certainly possible that your DPS is just not on the ball (or in fact does suck).

It’s also possible that your DPS doesn’t have the time to wind up properly.

Paladins generally start with a full tank. On the pull I’m pushing maximum DPS (for tanking), and I want to go quickly to keep Divine Plea up. Retadins can roll right along with me, as they don’t have any wind up time (if we’re speed pulling). Warriors have a bit of a wind up time, but if you’re just rolling along they shouldn’t lose too much rage, and shouldn’t fall behind too badly.

Hunters are very similar. They can pop shots out quickly, and can switch to Viper between pulls if they need a few seconds of mana regen. While Warlocks can Life Tap between pulls, they are generally dependant on DoTs for maximum damage. If they can’t get several Seeds of Corruption out, they’re reduced to using Hellfire – which is highly ineffective. Spriests are in a similar boat.

Rogues need CPs to do high DPS. If the target dies too quickly, they lose those CPs for their high output finishing moves. DKs need to spread diseases, Arcane Mages need to get their stacks up, etc.

Focus on the boss DPS

Instead of looking at the trash, focus on boss DPS. If after the first boss goes down your tank is still way above your DPS, and that DPS is lower than say 1500, you probably have an issue. Players in ilvl 200 gear (yes, even blues) should be able to pull around 1500 DPS, with an increase of about 1k DPS per tier level (plus or minus, your mileage may vary).

I guess my point here, is don’t crucify your DPS too early simply because they lag behind the tank in DPS. If they aren’t meeting the expectations (given their gear level) on a boss, feel free to kick away. Unfortunately for that freshly minted 80 though, they’re not going to touch my 4k tanking DPS.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Tanking Crib Sheet – Putricide

Ladies and gentlemen, I give you vs. Putricide – courtesy of Mongrr, our resident budding Warren Miller. Please remember to watch it in HD – it’s worth it. Tips and such on Putricide following the movie (bring popcorn, it’s a long one). Our raid comp is:

Tanks: Amathalanea(me) - Protadin – Putricide tank. Unbearabull - Feral – Abom tank/driver.

Melee DPS: Reaganomics – Retadin (he does 18kDPS, just ask him), Vierda – Rogue, Shamburger – Enhancement (tosses out many gratuitous CH).

Ranged DPS: Kainai – Mage, Mooshocka – Elemental, Cowculus – Boomkin,

Heals: Mongrr – Disc Priest (POV for the movie), Root - Tree





Setup

You’re going to want two tanks on this fight (three for 25 man), so figure out who gets to be the Abom and eat the slime pools. If you’re struggling with the hit cap, this would be a good fight to slide the taunt glyph in, as there will be a lot of tank swapping in Phase 3. Note: There are slime pools (green), oozes (green and orange/brown), and malleable ooze. Pools are bad and get eaten by the Abom. Oozes are DPS’d like mad, and slowed by the Abom. Malleable ooze is really bad (only comes in P2/P3), but the only way it will hit you is if some chuckle-headed DPS is standing behind/near you.

Phase 1

Main Tank (on Putricide)

· Pull the boss towards the orange gas tank. If you look in the video above at about the 20 second mark, you can see how far away from him when the first slime goes down. His hit box is big – but he follows real well.

· Bunch up on the green ooze that forms, along with the rest of the DPS. This will help spread the damage out if you don’t kill the ooze in time, and AOE melee effects will tick on Putri. PRO TIP: Don’t have the raid stack on the stunned member until after the 2nd slime pools are cast – otherwise you’ll probably kill someone.

· Drag Putri over to the green gas tank and wait for either Phase 2 or the orange ooze (P2 starts at 80%). You do NOT want an ooze out when P2 starts, so either stop DPS, or burn hard.

Abom Tank

· Your #1 job in life is to eat slime. Your #2 job is to slow the ooze when they spawn. If you have time, and your MT positions Putricide well, you can hit him with your armor debuff ability (especially useful if you have lots of melee).

· You need 50 energy for your slow ability – this is two whole pools, so don’t dawdle getting them consumed.

· Do not go into P2/P3 near any raid member, as your AoE will put them in the hurt locker quickly.

· Your buff/debuff is a disease, so don’t let anyone cleanse you.

Phase 2 80% - 1:16 in the video

Main Tank

· Pretty much a repeat of Phase 1, watch out for some gas containers on the ground (kite away) and the malleable ooze if DPS stands behind you. You will spend all of Phase 2 kiting between the two tanks as the corresponding oozes are killed.

Abom Tank

· See above. Make sure you’re eating the slimes as quickly as possible.

Phase 3 35% - 5:41 in the video

Main Tank

· Watch your timers closely, you cannot afford to have an ooze out (or forming) when you push to P3.

· Start in a corner and kite around the room. As long as nobody gets behind you, you’ll be able to effectively move around the room keeping your DPS out of the slime pools and the gas canisters. You can see an example of them at the 6:19 mark, they look like candles in the slime pool just in front of the Boomkin.

· Taunt rotate with your OT. You will get a debuff that quickly scales out of control. Try and tank swap at the 2,4,5,6 mark. If both tanks have 5 or 6 debuffs, you probably will not negotiate the encounter successfully (the debuff causes stacking raid damage).

· DO NOT LOSE THE DEBUFF. If you die, bubble out of the debuff, have it drop off to time, etc – Putri will heal back a ton of HP.

· Kite, kite, kite. He doesn’t hit too hard – so use CDs as needed.

Abom Tank

· Join the MT and play taunt tag. All the above refers to you at this point as well.

Wrapup

All in all this is a fun fight, even if Mongrr did complain that the FRAPSing is tough because of the music issues. Personally I don’t think this fight is nearly as long as Vashj or Kael’Thas – but Kael had his whole monologue you had to wade through.

Facelifter drops in 10 man, a nice tanking sword that should get bonus DPS for having a cool name. Much better looking than the mace from Marrowgar. Essentially the same weapon, trading hit and expertise.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Letting everyone tank/heal

John P. (Better known as the BBB) had an interesting post today that called for a radical shift in the MMO world – or at least in WoW today. In short, he wants to bring an end to the prima-donna status that many tanks and healers feel that they deserve. From Spinks calling for healers and tanks to get better rewards, to arrogant tanks that will leave their group high and dry on a whim, the situation has gotten steadily out of control.

BBB (if you read this, can I call you John? B cubed?) proposes that every class be given a talent tree that will allow them to tank or heal – but that will effectively reduce their DPS to zero. For the tanks, this means every ability would have massive threat multipliers attached to it, but a shield slam would crit for 5 instead of 5k. I don’t quite know how this would work for healing (rogues stab you with healing poison?), but the same general idea remains – you can heal, but you can’t DPS – maybe even add in a component so you take extra damage. BBB proposes that this would lead to more players stepping up and tanking/healing, and less of the idiocy that we see today.

He makes a few other great points, but you should really just read his post.

Why I think it won’t work – at least for now

First and foremost, not everyone wants to tank/heal – period. We already have four classes that are designed with a tank spec, and four healing classes as well. Spend five minutes in the LFG channel, or twenty using the LFG tool, as a DPS, and you’ll quickly see that there’s definitely a shortage of tanks and healers out there.

A large part of this can easily be attributed (at the end game) to the lack of gear that was available when 3.3 came out. Unless you were lucky and had a druid in your tank group, the odds were good that you saw very little tank plate trickle down to the offsets. Plus, you have those tank alts, that never got into a raid in the first place. Same goes for healing gear. I’m fairly certain I didn’t get my Broodmother Eye until after 3.3 had been out.

With the gear reset, and tier 9 gear falling into our laps, you would expect to see more tanks surfacing – but I don’t believe we are. While my data is by no means anything beyond my own experiences and what I’ve read from other bloggers – the sense is that we are still seeing near instant queues for tanks and healers, and slow queues for DPS. Even at the lower levels where the gear isn’t an issue (everyone has just quest rewards).

But why?

So why aren’t we seeing a fresh crop of tanks and healers surface, even if their only intent is to piggy back the system to level 80?

First, I think it has to come with the mindset that has taken root in the game (here’s where this post may get wordy and long). Tanking and healing have both been regaled as ‘more difficult’ or ‘harder’ tasks than just DPSing. Part of this thinking can be linked to the fact that even before tanks were doing 4k DPS in heroics (I was pulling 8k in ICC-10 the other night on trash – that’s sick), the fact remained that if the tank or healer go down – the odds are the rest of the party is soon to follow. Everyone I know has a pile of stories a mile long about fail tanks (especially DKs, more on that in a second), bad healers, etc. While there are just as many (if not more) stories about bad DPS – those aren’t as memorable because they can usually be carried through an instance.

Second, there is an inordinate amount of group pressure placed on anyone attempting to learn the ropes of tanking. From impatient DPS yelling ‘gogogogo’, to those that think everything can (and should) be AoE’d down within 1 GCD of pulling – the tank has a lot going on. Bad pull? Tank’s fault. Someone died? Lrn2holdagro. Heaven help the new Death Knight tank – especially if this is their first crack at tanking.

Next, you have the gear that is required in order to fill the tank/healer role properly. While Northrend has significantly more tanking pieces available than Outland did, most players who are only healing or tanking their way to 80 won’t want to invest in the gear (or spec) required to do the job properly – especially when it comes time to tanking heroics. Even though badges are literally falling off the trees, getting the upgrades you need takes time. If your heart was set on making your DK a PvP juggernaut, your odds of doing that and making a quality tank set are short.

Finally, there’s the stigma against new tanks in general. Don’t have 40k HP unbuffed? Noob, get out of my H-UK. DKs have a bad rap from the first days of everyone thinking all it took was Frost presence and a 2H to tank as a DK. I’ve got more hours tanking than anything else in the game, and my DK still has to work to get the respect out of a group. I’ve gotten many “Wow, a DK that doesn’t suck at tanking”, and several folks who apologized at the end of a run because they thought it couldn’t be done well (and we’re talking lvl 75 regular dungeons here).

Conclusion

BBB has it right – it will take a complete shift away from what we know now to make it work. Tanking and healing specs will have to be free. No extra gear can be required, there will have to be a mechanic for turning your AP into Stam (or as he mentions, spread the damage out more with everyone doing a little healing). I certainly think it’s a possible scenario for an MMO to pull off – but I don’t think WoW will ever go that route.

I’d be willing to bet that you’re still going to have five people standing there saying “Who’s tanking, I’m DPS”.