Monday, January 11, 2010

Don’t blame Blizzard – blame the user

WoW.com reported (posted?) today several interesting tidbits about Blizzard; mandatory authenticators (maybe), long queues for account retrieval (with pressure for reduced returns), and some social engineering hack against the administration team. While this may not come as a complete shock to everyone, I’m sure that there are more than a few folks who didn’t see this news coming. In particular, the news about the authenticators and the reduced return on a hacked account seems to be drawing the most heat. To be completely fair though, I think the HFB nerf that rogues got is getting more blue time.

Mandatory Authenticators

RSA SecureID authentication is not a new concept in the IT Security world. Strong authentication has always included multiple layers – both something you know, and something you have. Short of extreme circumstances, or the user being a complete idiot regarding security, it’s very difficult to get your hands on both of these keys. I’ve been using a SecureID for years now to access my servers remotely via Citrix, and I’ve never had an account compromise.

Blizzard authenticators are the exact same SecureID, just with a Blizzard logo on them (in fact I’ve grabbed the wrong one before) to keep their product name out there. In addition to having the fob keychain piece, you can also get an authenticator through the iTunes app store (for free if I remember correctly). If you want a physical device, I believe the cost is five dollars or some such. This basically covers the cost of shipping the thing, and pays for someone to put it in the envelope.

Personally, I like the idea of having authenticators be mandatory – but I’d wait until the shipment of Cataclysm to do it. Put an authenticator in every box of Diablo, Diablo 2, Starcraft, Warcraft, etc. This way there’s zero chance that someone who purchases the game won’t have one. Once you get home you can pitch the authenticator if you already have one, or add that authenticator to your account. It would certainly eliminate the need for extra shipping costs, and the actual cost of the authenticators would be covered by the reduced man-hours required for account retrieval.

Account retrieval queues

This is another point where I’m going to side with Blizzard. Looking over logs takes time, a lot of time. You have to be vigilant against the player who is trying to scam the system for more gold/epics, the habitual player who’s had four recoveries this month, and gather evidence at the same time. While this isn’t a criminal investigation (as opposed to say, someone stealing your corporate files), this is still an investigation that will probably lead to an account or three getting banned.

Let’s suppose however that each account retrieval takes about an hour to complete, from the time the ticket lands on someone’s desk – to the time you have your stuff back. While I don’t know the numbers on how many accounts are compromised every year, this person could handle (if they did nothing else) about two-thousand eighty (2080) account retrievals in a year. Even if that employee’s salary is say - $35,000/yr, you’re looking at purchasing 7000 authenticators (at $5 each). This means you could protect three times the number of people, for the cost of one employee’s salary (the number goes up higher when you consider all the other costs associated with retaining an employee).

What Blizzard has done in the interim, is to offer (as a choice, not mandatory) a quick band-aid solution in the way of a care package. In an official update, Blizzard stated that you’d get your soulbound items back (95% of your raid gear) along with 2500g and some emblems. So if you’re not in desperate need of those bank items, you can be back up and running almost instantly. Of course if you have full guild bank access, plus a sizeable stack of gold, this might not be the way to go.

One question I did have about the care packet though – is that issued to every toon on the account? If you made your maximum number of characters, that’s a pretty penny. Of course in my case, I’d be out quite a bit more than that in gold, plus the consumables I have squirreled away.

Social-Engineering

People, as a general rule, want to be helpful. Sure, in game you have your share of rudeness (internet anonymity at its best), but there are also tons of folks who are willing to go out of their way to help you out. This is no different in the real world, where a bit of smooth talking and fast thinking can get you in easier than following the rules.

Part of this comes from a lack of training, and part from the type of folks who generally hold the exploited positions. While I’m not going to write a book on Social Engineering (there are some good ones out there), I will say that I can understand how this kind of thing happens. Especially when the staff aren’t trained properly.

First, the administrators have a long queue of calls to handle. I’m sure they have some program that shows them who’s on hold, and how long they’ve been on hold. Second, they probably have a metric by which they are measured, stating that they should handle x calls in y time. When you combine these two factors, you have someone who wants to give you what you need (so they get a good review), and give it to you in a timely manner (so they can get to the next call and not get fired). This leads to all kinds of openings for exploitation, and I’m glad to see that Blizzard has recognized this and is working to fix it.

Conclusion

In short, it should be fairly simple to see why Blizzard is leaning towards mandatory authenticators, and has offered the care package instead of waiting for full account restoration. I expect we’ll see the care package sweetened in the near future, though I’m not sure we’ll ever see numbers on how many take the deal.

Edit: Should have posted this Friday, as WoW.com has put up a similar defense already.

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Festergut and Rotface Tanking Crib Sheet

Festergut and Rotface are the two bosses you’ll face before taking on Putricide in the Plagueworks wing of ICC. Neither of these bosses is exceptionally challenging from a tank point of view, but they do require coordination between the tanks.

Festergut

· You will get a stacking debuff on you that increases the damage you o by 10% per stack. You’ll explode when you get to 10 stacks, so have the OT taunt off when you get to 7 or 8 stacks.

· If you can wait for 8 stacks yours will be falling off just as the OT is getting to 8 stacks. You’ll also give the OT the best chance of surviving the giant AOE that will occur around this time.

· Paladins: Put your SS on your arcane mage if you have one – there is a constant AOE tick and the absorb will boost their spellpower. Use Divine Sacrifice when Festergut does his exhale. The raid should have lots of resist buffs by this time, but every bit helps.

· Coordinate cooldowns when you have 6+ stacks and Festergut has 3 of his buffs up.

· Divine Shield removes the stacks of debuffs (not sure about Hand of Protection, but I doubt it will).

· Stop attacking after you taunt, if you accidently get to 10 stacks, you’ll explode (and probably wipe the raid). Use Salvation and click off Righteous Fury to buy yourself some breathing room. (Thanks for the tip Wrathy and Ryan).

· Tank him in the dead middle of the room. If melee get in front of him you might get a DoT pool on your feet – so be prepared to slide.

Rotface

· One tank is required to hold Rotface. Your primary responsibility is to not fall asleep between ooze explosions when you’ll need to move Rotface to a portion of the floor that isn’t covered in slime, and then back to the center when the ooze bombs disappear.

o Paladins tanking Rotface should keep an eye on the 2nd tank to throw them a Hand of Freedom if they accidently get caught in slowing slime while kiting.

· Tank #2 doesn’t even really need to be a tank at all, though the taunt helps. Your job will be to run around the outside of the room kiting a giant slime and avoiding pools of goo. Raid members will be running to you in an effort to drop off their little slimes.

o Key note – the little slimes are not tauntable – once two get together to form a big slime, then you can taunt and start your laps.

o You’re basically a NASCAR driver for this fight, though you’ll dodge slime pools better if you go clockwise instead of counter-clockwise.

· Watch for raid members who don’t move fast enough, and they have two small oozes make a 2nd Big Ooze in the middle of the room – they hurt a lot and can quickly wipe your raid.

· Paladin tanks kiting can cleanse the poison themselves when they get close so they oozes merge nicely – the DOT hurts though, so pick your damage.

Conclusion

These two bosses don’t have any really difficult portions for the tanks, like say Firefighter (I’m sure heroic will be tougher). Festergut is all about managing your debuffs and resistance stacks, and Rotface is all about not falling asleep while kiting or standing in one spot.

Putricide pointers as soon as we get to him (hopefully up Friday morning).

Edited because I fail at reading tooltips.

Wiping with a purpose

Last night was one of the greatest raid nights that I’ve had in a long time. The trash was interesting, without being overly destructive, and there was just enough of it to actually feel like trash. We only faced two of the three bosses last night, but something even more important happened.

We wiped.

A lot.

Like, all night long – even on trash.

And it was glorious.

Wiping is good?

One of the things that has happened to us since we beat Anub in ToC 10H is that we’ve become complacent. ToC numbed us up, and the first four bosses in ICC didn’t do a whole lot to get the juices flowing. Mix in some holiday vacations, and you’ve got yourself a recipe for disaster.

Even though the two bosses we faced weren’t exceptionally difficult, they did employ some mechanics that took some getting used to. We also went in fairly blind, so we were learning the bosses as we went – an extremely fun process. I’m sorry to say that we didn’t get Rotface down, but we should have him fairly quickly on Thursday.

What I walked away with – not loot

A few things were immediately apparent last night, and that’s the sad (but true) fact that our critical thinking skills weren’t working well. Too many players were dying to the environmental damage, and making critical thinking errors. We’re going to have to tighten up our playstyle or we’re going to be in real trouble when the heroics come out.

So the wipes were good. I’m glad that the content is more challenging, and that we weren’t able to brute force our way through the content like we did with much of ToC. I honestly hope that the rest of ICC is this challenging.

Monday, January 4, 2010

Becoming a Raid Leader


First, if the thought of actually becoming a Raid Leader (RL) enters your mind, go and get your head checked. Seriously. Next to the MT and maybe the GM, it’s been my experience that Raid Leaders burn out faster than those nickel sparklers your old man bought you for New Year’s when you were five. It takes a special kind of stupid to volunteer for this task (yeah, I’m in my fourth year of doing it – so what), but if you’re dead set on this level of self-torture – here’s what you’ll need to know.

Are your goals aligned?

Before you even think about leading a raid, you need to sit down with your GM and the other officers and make sure that your raid goals, their raid goals, and more importantly – the goals of the guild, match up. Nothing will cause you to lose your sanity faster than thinking you’re about to lead the next Premonition into the future, only to discover you’ve got a group of casual RP’ers with families and kids. There’s certainly nothing wrong with that group of folks, but your goals probably aren’t going to mesh up well.

Get backing from the leadership

The raid leader has to be the one and only voice of direction in the middle of the raid. While it’s certainly acceptable, and even advisable, to get input from the raid (especially if you’re having difficulty with a boss), at the end – your voice has to be the final authority. In order to get this, you will need to ensure that the officers and GM are backing you, and not backstabbing you. Once your decisions are overridden, you will lose that command authority and are simply another voice on vent.

You also will want to ensure that your leadership style is in line with what the officers want. We used to joke that I could lead any guild (in BC) to success for four months (maybe six). During that time we’d down bosses that they’d never downed before, and clear content (for them) at a record pace. However at the end of that time, the guild would probably implode and die, largely due to my leadership style. Being the “Minus 50 DKP!” guy is funny on YouTube, but it isn’t always necessary.

Aim small, miss small

Before you try your hand at raid leading, get a group of mates together and try leading a five man heroic. If you can get your friends to agree, treat the heroic just like a raid, going through all the motions. While it may seem silly, it gets you used to providing boss strategies, directions, buff assignments, etc. You’ll feel a lot better when you go live in an actual raid, and you’ll have confidence in yourself (and your abilities).

Pay attention to your current Raid Leader, and try and get into as many PUG runs as you can to watch how others do it. Pick the styles and methods that work for you, and discard the ones that don’t. Not everyone has to lead the same to be effective, stick with what works for you.

Read EVERYTHING

Unless your guild is doing server firsts, or just relishes the blind attempts, read every scrap of information you can find on the internet. Tanking for Dummies, TankSpot, YouTube, Wowwiki, etc. There is a veritable fountain of information out there, and information is power in the world of raid leading.

The more you know before you walk in, the better prepared you will be to lead something. Even if you’ve seen the fight a hundred times from your fire-mage, coordinating 9/24 other people is tougher than it looks. This is doubly true if you’re a healer/dps that is trying to keep everyone alive and DPS numbers up. Keeping your UI free of clutter, and being situaltionally aware will help you get through this.

Add-ons that help

While it’s certainly possible to raid add-on free (I’ve done it a few times either to show I could, or because a patch broke my beautiful UI), leading becomes much more difficult without some handy tools. Fortunately add-ons have come a long way since I first used CT_RaidAssist, and it’s no longer necessary to have everyone in the raid get a specific add-on. With the implementation of portals and quick access to repair agents, keeping track of everyone’s repair status is also slightly less crucial. You will of course always have that one guy who needs a repair bot two pulls after one has been dropped.

· Big Brother – this handy add-on will do a quick buff/flask check. You can see who is missing priest/pally buffs, well fed, or is un-flasked. It will even check if someone is double elixired instead of flasked. You can report the information to a specific /say channel, or directly to the raid.

· Recount – While this will be a useful tool for looking at DPS (please, I’m begging you, look at more than the raw DPS output), it’s the GrimReaper/Death tab you’re most interested in. You need to know if that warlock just stood in the Giant Big (usually fire/poison/cleave), or if he pulled agro and got punched in the face. Recount is extremely powerful, and could use an article all of its own.

· Some kind of raid frames – I don’t care if you use the Blizzard standard frames, Grid, whatever. You need to keep an eye on who’s alive, who’s got a debuff, etc.

· Boss timers – Blizzard has done a lot to help relieve the need for boss timers, but using BigWigs/DBM will help you track boss abilities and time your raid events.

· Cooldown timer – instantly see what long cooldowns have been use (Battle Rez, DI, etc).

Remember addons are supposed to be helpful. Don’t get so wrapped up in the finer details that you lose picture of the whole raid.

Conclusion

Becoming a Raid Leader is a big step, and is a big responsibility with little tangible reward. Don’t be afraid to try it once or twice to see if it fits you. Some take to it like a duck to water, others – well not so much.